Hardcover, 158 pages
English language
Published June 23, 2020 by Tor.
The Order of the Pure Moon Reflected in Water
by Zen Cho
4 stars
(2 reviews)
A bandit walks into a coffeehouse, and it all goes downhill from there. Guet Imm, a young votary of the Order of the Pure Moon, joins up with an eclectic group of thieves (whether they like it or not) in order to protect a sacred object, and finds herself in a far more complicated situation than she could have ever imagined.
The Order of the Pure Moon Reflected in Water
4 stars
I read this as a part of the #SFFBookClub for March. I voted for this book largely because I had enjoyed Zen Cho's Sorcerer to the Crown and wanted to read more from her.
To sum up the book, it's a wuxia novella that follows a bandit group along with ex-nun Guet Imm. Guet Imm in the first scene loses her job at a coffee shop because of said bandits and insists on joining said gang. Very queer; some gender stuff going on; the gang itself is sort of a found family that sticks up for each other even when they don't get along. It's hard to talk about too much more without getting into spoilers. It's far more about characterization and shifting identities due to wartime loss than about magical fight scenes.
I was not expecting to find this book so funny and to have such great banter. Guet …
I read this as a part of the #SFFBookClub for March. I voted for this book largely because I had enjoyed Zen Cho's Sorcerer to the Crown and wanted to read more from her.
To sum up the book, it's a wuxia novella that follows a bandit group along with ex-nun Guet Imm. Guet Imm in the first scene loses her job at a coffee shop because of said bandits and insists on joining said gang. Very queer; some gender stuff going on; the gang itself is sort of a found family that sticks up for each other even when they don't get along. It's hard to talk about too much more without getting into spoilers. It's far more about characterization and shifting identities due to wartime loss than about magical fight scenes.
I was not expecting to find this book so funny and to have such great banter. Guet Imm is an optimistic force of nature whose personality carries the book. Her dynamic with the grumpy Tet Sang and amused Fung Cheung made the book a lot of fun. She shows up to the group of bandits and insists that she's joining them despite being already paid off, despite not being able to cook, and also despite making it very clear that she will not sleep with any of them. This sort of dynamic continues elsewhere where Guet Imm innocently and irreverently inserts herself into situations (fully knowing what she's doing) while everybody else is amused or exasperated. (Although they are definitely not the same character, I think there are some personality vibe parallels with Prunella from Sorcerer to the Crown here, which probably added to my enjoyment.)
If I had any complaint, I feel like the focus on banter and main characters left some of the other place and character details out of focus. One amusing example is the scene where Guet Imm shows up to join the group and multiple bandits are introduced out of thin air. There's an ongoing conversation, and Ah Boon (never mentioned before) tries to flirt with Guet Imm. A few conversation beats later, Fung Cheung says "oh you can ask Rimau about religion" and Rimau (never mentioned before) chimes in. Then, Fung Cheung mentions Ah Yee's cooking and Ah Yee (also never mentioned before) chimes in a reply. Maybe this is supposed to be an intentionally comedic clown car introduction of the bandit troupe (or some trope that went over my head), but it took a reread to make sure I understood who all was even in the scene.
Overall, I enjoyed this a lot. Would recommend.